Kelly, of Burdett, is a graduate of Watkins Glen High School. She plans to study elementary and special education at Mansfield University. The daughter of Craig and Cynthia Kelly, she has been active with the National Honor Society, varsity club, edited the Watkins Glen yearbook and competed on the school's volleyball, track and softball teams. She has volunteered for six years with the Leading the Way Therapeutic Horseback Riding Program and worked as a counselor at the Watkins Glen Summer Camp.

 Dombroski, of Dundee, is a graduate of Bradford Central School. The daughter of Joseph and Tammy Dombroski, she plans to study physical therapy at Utica College. Dombroski has participated with Bradford's soccer, basketball and softball teams, was active with the yearbook, senior play, band and chorus and was a member of the school's student council, Academic All-Stars and National Honor Society. She helped organize a clothing drive at her school, helped with a fundraiser at the Tyrone Volunteer Fire Department and assisted with a Cinderella softball team.